Compare

Carnegie vs Murrumbeena

Name: Carnegie vs Murrumbeena — 2021 Census comparison
Creator: Australian Bureau of Statistics
License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/

Suburb / Locality comparison ≈ 1.4 km apart · Carnegie profile · Murrumbeena profile

Carnegie Murrumbeena

Carnegie and Murrumbeena are neighbouring areas in Victoria with different housing and cultural profiles. Carnegie has a higher share of people born overseas (43.4%) and more residents who use another language at home (38.4%). It is also more likely to have renters (42.3%) and people living alone (35.0%). Murrumbeena has more detached houses (45.6%) and larger homes, with 52.7% having three or more bedrooms compared to 41.1% in Carnegie. Murrumbeena also has more public transport stops and a higher number of walkable amenities per resident.

These two areas are very similar in their typical weekly personal income, which sits around $1,000 for both. However, the gap in First Nations language use is far higher in Carnegie, where 10.5% of people speak such a language compared to 0.0% in Murrumbeena. Both areas are far above the national figure for people born overseas, though Carnegie's share of recent arrivals is well higher than in Murrumbeena.

Open map →

Where they differ most

Separate houses: 13.6 pts higher in Murrumbeena 3+ bedrooms: 11.7 pts higher in Murrumbeena Population: 7,913 larger in Carnegie Born overseas: 8.9 pts higher in Carnegie Other language: 7.1 pts higher in Carnegie

Demographics & Identity

Population in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +7,913 larger in Carnegie gap steady

17,909 89th pct 9,996 87th pct

Median age in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +1 yrs older in Murrumbeena gap steady

36 yrs 17th pct 37 yrs 20th pct

Age structure

37.7% Young adults (25–44) ◂ +4.9 pts 32.9%

21.6% Older adults (45–64) +3.4 pts ▸ 25.0%

13.9% Children (0–14) +2.3 pts ▸ 16.2%

15.2% Seniors (65+) ◂ +1.1 pts 14.2%

11.6% Youth (15–24) +0.1 pts ▸ 11.7%

Marital status

41.0% Married +5.7 pts ▸ 46.7%

44.8% Never married ◂ +4.4 pts 40.4%

7.8% Divorced ◂ +1.0 pts 6.8%

4.3% Widowed ◂ +0.3 pts 3.9%

2.2% Separated +0.1 pts ▸ 2.3%

Age & sex structure

Carnegie Murrumbeena

Bars show the share of each area's own population, so differently sized areas stay comparable.

Ancestry & Birthplace

Country of birth

53.7% Australia +9.4 pts ▸ 63.1%

9.2% India ◂ +3.3 pts 5.8%

6.2% China ◂ +2.2 pts 4.0%

2.3% England ◂ +0.2 pts 2.1%

1.6% New Zealand even 1.5%

1.1% South Africa ◂ +0.2 pts 0.9%

1.0% Vietnam +0.1 pts ▸ 1.1%

0.9% Philippines ◂ +0.1 pts 0.8%

0.6% Nepal +0.1 pts ▸ 0.8%

0.5% Italy +0.2 pts ▸ 0.7%

Ancestry

22.9% English +3.1 pts ▸ 26.0%

20.3% Australian +3.4 pts ▸ 23.7%

12.7% Chinese ◂ +2.7 pts 9.9%

9.2% Irish +1.6 pts ▸ 10.8%

8.7% Indian ◂ +2.2 pts 6.5%

7.4% Scottish +1.0 pts ▸ 8.4%

5.5% Greek +2.3 pts ▸ 7.8%

4.2% Italian +1.8 pts ▸ 6.0%

2.9% German +0.5 pts ▸ 3.5%

1.5% Dutch +0.2 pts ▸ 1.7%

1.2% Vietnamese +0.1 pts ▸ 1.3%

1.2% Filipino even 1.2%

Language

Language used at home

58.2% English only +7.9 pts ▸ 66.1%

7.4% Mandarin ◂ +2.0 pts 5.4%

3.9% Greek +1.4 pts ▸ 5.4%

2.0% Cantonese ◂ +0.8 pts 1.3%

2.0% Hindi ◂ +0.8 pts 1.2%

0.8% Italian +0.4 pts ▸ 1.2%

0.9% Vietnamese even 1.0%

0.3% Tagalog +0.1 pts ▸ 0.4%

0.4% Punjabi even 0.4%

0.3% Arabic +0.1 pts ▸ 0.4%

Religion

Religious affiliation

42.1% No religion ◂ +1.2 pts 40.8%

32.2% Christianity +8.2 pts ▸ 40.4%

9.3% Hinduism ◂ +3.4 pts 5.9%

6.2% Judaism ◂ +2.8 pts 3.4%

5.3% Not stated ◂ +1.0 pts 4.4%

3.0% Buddhism ◂ +0.1 pts 3.0%

1.2% Islam +0.2 pts ▸ 1.3%

0.7% Other religions even 0.8%

Education & Qualifications

Schools/1k kids in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +0.03 more in Murrumbeena

1.21 12th pct 1.24 13th pct

Schools ≤3 km in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +2 more in Carnegie

45 91st pct 43 91st pct

Avg size in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +25 larger in Murrumbeena

543 77th pct 568 80th pct

ICSEA in Carnegie in Murrumbeena even

1,129 97th pct 1,127 97th pct

Highest year of school

79.4% Year 12 ◂ +0.2 pts 79.2%

5.4% Year 11 +0.7 pts ▸ 6.1%

4.8% Year 9 or below +1.0 pts ▸ 5.9%

5.6% Year 10 +0.2 pts ▸ 5.9%

Highest qualification level

40.3% Bachelor degree +1.2 pts ▸ 41.5%

21.1% Postgraduate degree ◂ +2.5 pts 18.6%

12.3% Advanced diploma / diploma +0.7 pts ▸ 13.0%

10.2% Certificate III / IV +1.4 pts ▸ 11.5%

5.2% Graduate diploma / certificate +1.1 pts ▸ 6.3%

0.7% Certificate I / II even 0.8%

Field of qualification

24.0% Management & commerce +1.0 pts ▸ 25.0%

11.9% Society & culture +0.5 pts ▸ 12.4%

10.6% Engineering & related +0.3 pts ▸ 10.9%

9.2% Health +0.9 pts ▸ 10.2%

7.0% Education +1.3 pts ▸ 8.3%

7.9% Information technology ◂ +1.0 pts 6.9%

6.2% Creative arts ◂ +0.3 pts 5.9%

5.7% Natural & physical sciences ◂ +0.4 pts 5.4%

3.6% Architecture & building +0.2 pts ▸ 3.8%

3.4% Food, hospitality & personal services ◂ +0.3 pts 3.1%

0.9% Agriculture & environment even 0.9%

Income

Personal income in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +$30 higher in Murrumbeena gap narrowing

$1,005 82nd pct $1,035 85th pct

Household income in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +$179 higher in Murrumbeena gap widening

$1,878 69th pct $2,057 77th pct

Family income in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +$222 higher in Murrumbeena gap widening

$2,545 83rd pct $2,767 88th pct

Household income distribution

30.3% $1,500–$2,999 ◂ +1.7 pts 28.6%

22.7% $650–$1,499 even 22.7%

16.2% $4,000 or more +4.1 pts ▸ 20.2%

16.0% Under $650 ◂ +3.1 pts 12.8%

10.1% $3,000–$3,999 +0.8 pts ▸ 10.9%

Personal income distribution

33.8% Under $650 ◂ +0.5 pts 33.4%

30.3% $650–$1,499 ◂ +1.0 pts 29.4%

23.0% $1,500–$2,999 +2.1 pts ▸ 25.1%

7.7% $3,000 or more +0.8 pts ▸ 8.5%

Health & Disability

Long-term health conditions reported

8.5% Mental health ◂ +0.4 pts 8.1%

8.1% Other condition even 8.1%

7.3% Asthma +0.3 pts ▸ 7.6%

6.0% Arthritis ◂ +0.1 pts 5.9%

3.8% Diabetes ◂ +0.5 pts 3.4%

3.1% Heart disease ◂ +0.5 pts 2.6%

2.4% Cancer +0.3 pts ▸ 2.7%

1.0% Lung condition ◂ +0.1 pts 0.9%

0.7% Stroke +0.1 pts ▸ 0.8%

0.5% Dementia +0.3 pts ▸ 0.8%

Number of long-term health conditions

70.0% None +0.7 pts ▸ 70.7%

17.5% One condition +0.7 pts ▸ 18.2%

4.7% Two conditions ◂ +0.1 pts 4.6%

2.1% Three or more ◂ +0.3 pts 1.8%

Community Participation

First Nations

First Nations people in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +29 larger in Carnegie

57 78th pct 28 72nd pct

Median age in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +2 yrs older in Murrumbeena

29 yrs 60th pct 31 yrs 66th pct

Median income in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +$684 higher in Murrumbeena

$524 36th pct $1,208 87th pct

Household income in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +$458 higher in Murrumbeena

$1,625 47th pct $2,083 65th pct

Family & Households

Household size in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +0.2 larger in Murrumbeena gap widening

2.2 24th pct 2.4 43rd pct

Family composition

55.6% Couples with children +5.5 pts ▸ 61.2%

32.9% Couples without children ◂ +4.8 pts 28.1%

9.4% One-parent families ◂ +0.1 pts 9.3%

2.0% Other families ◂ +0.6 pts 1.5%

Household size

35.0% 1 person ◂ +3.9 pts 31.1%

33.8% 2 people ◂ +2.3 pts 31.5%

12.4% 4 people +4.1 pts ▸ 16.4%

14.4% 3 people +0.7 pts ▸ 15.1%

3.7% 5 people +1.0 pts ▸ 4.7%

0.8% 6 or more +0.5 pts ▸ 1.3%

Housing & Dwellings

Rent in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +$9 higher in Carnegie gap steady

$395 81st pct $386 79th pct

Mortgage in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +$127 higher in Murrumbeena gap widening

$2,040 74th pct $2,167 80th pct

People / bedroom in Carnegie in Murrumbeena even gap steady

0.90 86th pct 0.90 86th pct

How homes are owned or rented

42.3% Rented ◂ +5.8 pts 36.4%

28.9% Owned with a mortgage +3.2 pts ▸ 32.1%

26.2% Owned outright +3.3 pts ▸ 29.5%

1.4% Other tenure ◂ +0.5 pts 0.9%

1.1% Not stated ◂ +0.2 pts 0.9%

Types of homes

31.9% Separate house +13.6 pts ▸ 45.6%

39.7% Flat or apartment ◂ +10.8 pts 28.8%

28.2% Townhouse / semi-detached ◂ +2.8 pts 25.4%

0.1% Other dwelling even 0.1%

Bedrooms per home

41.3% 2 bedrooms ◂ +12.3 pts 29.1%

26.7% 3 bedrooms +4.9 pts ▸ 31.5%

11.6% 4 bedrooms +5.7 pts ▸ 17.3%

16.0% 1 bedroom +0.9 pts ▸ 17.0%

2.8% 5 or more +1.1 pts ▸ 3.9%

0.5% Studio / none ◂ +0.2 pts 0.3%

Weekly rent distribution

48.6% $350–$549 ◂ +8.3 pts 40.3%

29.3% $200–$349 +5.4 pts ▸ 34.6%

11.1% $550–$749 +0.9 pts ▸ 12.0%

5.3% Under $200 even 5.3%

3.7% $750 or more +1.6 pts ▸ 5.2%

Monthly mortgage distribution

31.9% $1,800–$2,999 ◂ +4.7 pts 27.2%

26.3% $3,000 or more +5.3 pts ▸ 31.6%

24.4% $1,000–$1,799 ◂ +4.6 pts 19.8%

11.7% Under $1,000 +2.5 pts ▸ 14.3%

Transport & Vehicles

PT stops in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +6 more in Carnegie

64 88th pct 58 88th pct

Stops/1k in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +2.23 more in Murrumbeena

3.57 72nd pct 5.80 81st pct

Departures/1k in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +780.7 more in Murrumbeena

1,339.3 88th pct 2,119.9 92nd pct

PT routes in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +4 more in Murrumbeena

10 86th pct 14 86th pct

Stop walk in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +1 longer in Carnegie

2 14th pct 1 0th pct

Drive to city in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +1 longer in Murrumbeena

16 13th pct 17 14th pct

Reach 30 min in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +17,469 more in Carnegie

52,935 87th pct 35,466 86th pct

Reach 45 min in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +71,573 more in Carnegie

286,552 88th pct 214,979 87th pct

Transit to city in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +3 longer in Murrumbeena

48 32nd pct 51 38th pct

How people get to work

39.7% Worked at home ◂ +0.7 pts 39.0%

34.3% Car (driver) +1.9 pts ▸ 36.1%

5.0% Train ◂ +0.5 pts 4.5%

2.0% Car (passenger) +0.1 pts ▸ 2.1%

1.9% Walked ◂ +0.1 pts 1.8%

0.7% Bicycle +0.2 pts ▸ 0.8%

0.7% Bus +0.1 pts ▸ 0.8%

Motor vehicles per home

51.1% 1 vehicle ◂ +6.0 pts 45.1%

28.3% 2 vehicles +5.8 pts ▸ 34.2%

12.8% No vehicle ◂ +3.5 pts 9.3%

5.2% 3 vehicles +2.3 pts ▸ 7.5%

2.6% 4 or more +1.2 pts ▸ 3.7%

Migration & Movement

Jobs & Industry

Industries people work in

14.3% Professional & technical ◂ +1.1 pts 13.2%

13.6% Health care & social assistance ◂ +0.1 pts 13.6%

10.4% Education & training +0.9 pts ▸ 11.4%

9.5% Retail trade even 9.5%

5.7% Construction +1.0 pts ▸ 6.7%

6.5% Finance & insurance ◂ +0.1 pts 6.4%

6.0% Accommodation & food ◂ +0.2 pts 5.7%

5.6% Public administration & safety +0.1 pts ▸ 5.7%

4.8% Manufacturing +0.1 pts ▸ 4.9%

3.3% Administrative & support even 3.4%

3.3% Transport & warehousing ◂ +0.4 pts 2.9%

2.6% Wholesale trade even 2.6%

Occupations people work in

37.3% Professionals ◂ +1.5 pts 35.8%

14.9% Managers +1.2 pts ▸ 16.1%

12.6% Clerical & administrative +0.2 pts ▸ 12.8%

8.8% Community & personal service even 8.8%

8.5% Technicians & trades +0.2 pts ▸ 8.7%

7.7% Sales workers +0.3 pts ▸ 8.0%

5.2% Labourers even 5.2%

2.9% Machinery operators & drivers +0.2 pts ▸ 3.1%

Walkability

Walk score in Carnegie in Murrumbeena +0.1 higher in Murrumbeena

8.5 100th pct 8.6 100th pct

Types ≤15 min in Carnegie in Murrumbeena even

7.9 99th pct 7.9 99th pct

15-min city in Carnegie in Murrumbeena even